Achilles Tendinopathy (Insertional and Non-Insertional)

Assoc. Prof. Mehmet DEMIREL· Istanbul University, School of Medicine, Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology
Apr 25, 2026

Definition

  • Achilles tendinopathy is a chronic clinical syndrome.

  • Clinically characterized by:

    • pain,

    • swelling,

    • functional impairment of the Achilles tendon.

  • Histopathologically:

    • acute inflammatory cells (macrophages, neutrophils) are absent.

  • Represents a degenerative rather than inflammatory condition.


Anatomical Classification

  • Insertional Achilles Tendinopathy (IAT)

    • Involves the calcaneal insertion.

    • First 2 cm of the tendon.

  • Non-Insertional Achilles Tendinopathy (NIAT)

    • Involves the mid-portion of the tendon.

    • Located 2–6 cm proximal to the calcaneal insertion.


Clinical Importance of Anatomical Distinction

  • Insertional and non-insertional tendinopathies represent:

    • different clinical entities,

    • different epidemiology,

    • different pathophysiology,

    • different treatment approaches.

  • Accurate differentiation is essential for:

    • diagnosis,

    • treatment planning.


Epidemiology

  • Based on current concepts review data.

  • Non-Insertional Tendinopathy

    • More common in:

      • younger,

      • physically active individuals,

      • athletes (runners, basketball players).

  • Insertional Tendinopathy

    • More common in:

      • middle-aged and older individuals,

      • less active or sedentary patients,

      • overweight or former athletes.


Pathophysiology and Risk Factors

Impaired Tendon Healing Capacity

  • Central mechanism in Achilles tendinopathy.

  • Results in:

    • chronic,

    • progressive,

    • irreversible structural damage.


Intrinsic Risk Factors

  • Metabolic disorders:

    • diabetes mellitus,

    • hypercholesterolemia,

    • hyperuricemia.

  • Inflammatory conditions.

  • Hypoxic stress.

  • Genetic predisposition.


Extrinsic Risk Factors

  • Repetitive overload.

  • Sudden increase in training intensity.

  • Abrupt changes in training programs.

  • Medication use:

    • corticosteroids,

    • aromatase inhibitors,

    • fluoroquinolone antibiotics,

    • statins.


Structural Tendon Changes

  • Tendon degeneration.

  • Neovascularization and neoinnervation.

  • Increased tenocyte activity.

  • Increased glycosaminoglycan and water content.

  • Tendon thickening.

  • Collagen disorganization:

    • type I collagen decreases,

    • type III collagen increases.

  • Parallel collagen alignment converts to a wavy pattern.


Pain Generation

  • Neovascularization and neoinnervation contribute to pain.

  • Degenerative matrix interferes with tendon healing.


Diagnosis – Clinical Evaluation

Symptoms

  • Classic clinical triad:

    • pain,

    • swelling,

    • functional limitation.

  • Acute phase:

    • pain during first steps of the day,

    • pain at the beginning of exercise,

    • symptoms may decrease with activity.

  • Chronic phase:

    • pain persists during rest.


Inspection

  • Evaluation of:

    • foot and ankle alignment,

    • pes cavus or pes planus deformity.


Palpation

  • Localized tenderness:

    • insertional region (IAT),

    • mid-portion fusiform swelling (NIAT).

  • Mid-portion swelling is:

    • tender,

    • mobile,

    • fusiform.


Physical Examination – Special Tests

Gastrocnemius Contracture

  • Frequently associated.

  • Especially relevant when:

    • stiffness occurs after prolonged activity.

  • Influences treatment planning.

  • Silfverskiöld test used for assessment.


Painful Arc Sign and Royal London Test

  • Demonstrate:

    • moderate diagnostic sensitivity,

    • moderate diagnostic specificity.

  • Provide supportive clinical information.


Imaging

Plain Radiography

  • First-line and most commonly used modality.

  • Findings may include:

    • soft tissue thickening,

    • calcifications,

    • Haglund morphology (in insertional cases).


Ultrasound and MRI

  • MRI:

    • most informative imaging modality.

  • Useful for:

    • insertional and non-insertional tendinopathy.

  • Demonstrates:

    • tendon thickening,

    • degenerative architecture,

    • intratendinous signal changes,

    • retrocalcaneal bursitis,

    • Haglund morphology.


Is Imaging Always Required?

  • Imaging is not mandatory when all of the following are present:

    • localized pain at insertional or mid-portion region,

    • load-related pain during activity,

    • localized tendon thickening,

    • pain with palpation.

  • In such cases:

    • diagnosis can be established clinically,

    • treatment may be initiated without imaging.


Imaging Selection Strategy

  • Ultrasound:

    • preferred initial modality.

  • MRI:

    • used when ultrasound is unavailable,

    • required for surgical planning.

  • X-ray:

    • useful for evaluating bony morphology,

    • particularly in insertional tendinopathy.


Treatment Overview

  • Initial treatment is always non-operative.

  • Two conceptual approaches:

    • “wait and see” (acute inflammation model),

    • “active treatment” (chronic degenerative model).

  • Achilles tendinopathy corresponds to:

    • a chronic degenerative condition.


Non-Operative Treatment – Core Approach

  • Patient education.

  • Physical therapy.

  • Activity modification.

  • Chronic disease course requires:

    • patience,

    • long-term adherence.


Activity Modification

  • Temporary cessation of pain-provoking activity.

  • Substitution with alternative activities.

  • Gradual return to sport.


Physical Therapy

  • Must be included in initial treatment.

  • Focuses on:

    • eccentric loading of gastrocnemius–soleus complex.

  • Goal:

    • restore tendon load tolerance.


Eccentric Exercise Protocols

  • Protocol selection depends on:

    • tendinopathy location.

  • Commonly used protocols:

    • Alfredson eccentric protocol,

    • Silbernagel eccentric–concentric protocol,

    • Beyer heavy–slow resistance exercises,

    • Stanish eccentric strengthening.


Alfredson Protocol

  • Most widely used protocol.

  • Performed on flat ground.

  • Knee extended:

    • 3 sets × 15 repetitions.

  • Knee flexed:

    • 3 sets × 15 repetitions.

  • Twice daily.

  • Total:

    • 180 repetitions per day.

  • Adaptations required for insertional tendinopathy.


NSAIDs

  • No effect on:

    • collagen gene expression,

    • tendon repair.

  • Provide:

    • moderate analgesic effect.

  • Do not enhance physical therapy outcomes.

  • Associated with:

    • significant side effects.

  • Use limited to short-term pain control.


Heel Lifts

  • Reduce Achilles tendon load.

  • Improve pain and function.

  • Should not be used as:

    • sole treatment modality.

  • Serve as adjunct to physical therapy.


Stepwise Non-Operative Treatment

First-Line

  • Patient education.

  • Eccentric exercises.

  • NSAIDs.

  • Heel lifts.

Second-Line

  • ESWT.

  • Injection therapies:

    • PRP,

    • corticosteroid (with caution),

    • stromal vascular fraction,

    • hyaluronic acid,

    • prolotherapy,

    • high-volume injection.

  • Acupuncture.


Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy (ESWT)

  • Proposed mechanisms:

    • removal of damaged matrix via pro-inflammatory response,

    • stimulation of anabolic repair processes.

  • Demonstrated safety in:

    • insertional and non-insertional tendinopathy.

  • Represents:

    • minimally invasive second-line option.


Injection Therapies

  • PRP:

    • most extensively studied,

    • demonstrated safety and efficacy,

    • preferred second-line injection.

  • Corticosteroids:

    • associated with increased rupture risk,

    • not suitable for routine use.


Indications for Surgery

  • Reserved for:

    • persistent cases,

    • failure of ≥6 months of appropriate conservative treatment.

  • Approximately 30% of patients may require surgery.


Surgical Treatment Overview

  • Goal:

    • pain relief,

    • functional improvement.

  • Surgical strategy differs between:

    • insertional,

    • non-insertional tendinopathy.


Insertional Achilles Tendinopathy – Surgical Options

  • Open debridement and decompression.

  • Endoscopic calcaneoplasty.

  • Zadek osteotomy.

  • Osteotomies.

  • Tendon augmentation procedures.


Open Debridement and Decompression

  • Reported success rates:

    • 70–90%.

  • Most extensively studied technique.

  • Allows:

    • adequate exposure,

    • FHL transfer if required.

  • Low risk of sural nerve injury.

  • Skin irritation remains a concern.


Surgical Approaches

  • Midline longitudinal.

  • Lateral longitudinal.

  • Cincinnati transverse.

  • Less invasive approaches:

    • lower wound complication rates,

    • limited access for tendon transfer.


Safe Tendon Detachment Limits

  • <50% detachment:

    • low rerupture risk,

    • safe debridement.

·       50% detachment:

  • reattachment required,

  • single-row or double-row anchor repair.

  • Complete detachment:

    • double-row repair preferred.


Tendon Augmentation

  • Indicated when:

o   50% tendon resection required.

  • Common graft choices:

    • flexor hallucis longus,

    • flexor digitorum longus,

    • peroneus brevis,

    • patellar tendon,

    • quadriceps tendon,

    • hamstring autograft.


Endoscopic Calcaneoplasty

  • Advantages:

    • minimally invasive,

    • fewer wound complications.

  • Limitations:

    • insufficient evidence as standalone treatment,

    • technical difficulty in intratendinous calcification removal.

  • Best suited for:

    • isolated posterosuperior calcaneal prominence.


Zadek Osteotomy

  • Dorsal closing-wedge calcaneal osteotomy.

  • Recently gained popularity.

  • Performed:

    • open or percutaneously.

  • Applicable to:

    • Haglund deformity,

    • insertional tendinopathy.


Mechanism of Zadek Osteotomy

  • Anterior rotation of posterosuperior tuberosity.

  • Proximal shift of Achilles insertion.

  • Reduced Achilles tendon tension.

  • Decreased retrocalcaneal pressure.

  • Reduced impingement.


Clinical Outcomes of Zadek Osteotomy

  • Reported outcomes:

    • significant pain relief,

    • functional improvement.

  • Patient satisfaction:

o   90%.

  • Complication rate:

    • ~10% overall,

    • ~5% with percutaneous technique.

  • Comparative studies:

    • similar clinical outcomes to open calcaneoplasty,

    • lower complication rates.


Non-Insertional Achilles Tendinopathy – Surgical Options

  • Percutaneous longitudinal tenotomy.

  • Paratenon stripping.

  • Open debridement and repair.

  • Tendon augmentation.


Percutaneous Longitudinal Tenotomy

  • Indicated for:

    • mild to moderate focal tendinopathy,

    • patients at high wound-risk (diabetes, smoking, elderly).

  • Ultrasound-guided technique.

  • Reported success rate:

    • ~80%.

  • Lower complication profile.


Open Debridement and Repair

  • Indicated for:

    • advanced,

    • diffuse tendinopathy.

  • Tendon augmentation often required.

  • Common grafts:

    • FHL,

    • plantaris tendon.


Take-Home Messages

  • Tendinopathy is a degenerative condition.

  • MRI is not mandatory for initial diagnosis.

  • NSAIDs and heel lifts alone are insufficient.

  • Eccentric loading is essential.

  • PRP represents a safer second-line injection.

  • Surgical treatment must be individualized.

  • Percutaneous techniques are effective in selected cases.