Functional Anatomy: Muscle Forces and Foot Deformities

1. Tibialis Posterior → Adult Acquired Flatfoot / Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity (AAFD / PCFD)

  • Anatomy & Normal Function

    • Courses posterior to medial malleolus; inserts primarily on the navicular and medial midfoot.

    • Major dynamic stabilizer of the medial longitudinal arch.

    • Controls subtalar inversion, supports talonavicular joint, and contributes to midfoot locking mechanism during push-off.

  • Pathoanatomy         

    • Tendon degeneration, elongation, or rupture → progressive loss of medial support.

    • Secondary failure of static stabilizers: spring ligament, deltoid ligament, talonavicular capsule, interosseous ligaments.

    • Leads to:

      • Hindfoot valgus and peritalar subluxation

      • Medial arch collapse

      • Talus plantarflexion/adduction and forefoot abduction (“too many toes”)

  • Imaging

    • Weight-bearing AP Foot

      • Talonavicular uncoverage (%) – often increased

      • Talus–1st Metatarsal Angle (AP Meary’s) – often increased

      • Talo–calcaneal angle (Kite angle) – often increased

    • Weight-bearing Lateral Foot

      • Meary’s Angle (Talo–1st MT): plantar apex shift

      • Calcaneal Pitch: often decreased

      • Talus declination angle: increased

  • Gait & Kinetic Chain Effects

    • Excessive pronation during stance; talar internal rotation with increased subtalar eversion.

    • Ground reaction force shifts laterally; tibial internal rotation increases.

    • May contribute to valgus knee moments and patellofemoral maltracking symptoms.

  • Clinical Clues

    • Medial ankle pain and tenderness along the posterior tibial tendon.

    • “Too many toes sign” on posterior inspection.

    • Single heel-rise test: weakness or inability to invert heel into varus.

  • Management Overview

    • Stage I (Early / flexible stages)

      • Immobilization for painful tenosynovitis, orthotics (medial arch support), stretching and strengthening.

    • Stage II (flexible deformity)

      • Goals: restore medial column alignment and replace tendon function.

      • Common combinations:

        • FDL transfer to navicular

        • Medializing calcaneal osteotomy

        • ± lateral column lengthening

        • ± spring ligament reconstruction

        • ± gastrocnemius recession/Achilles lengthening

    • Stage III–IV (rigid / arthritic deformity)

      • Fusion-based procedures (double or triple arthrodesis).

    • Clinical Message: Early identification and treatment slow progression and reduce surgical complexity.

2. Peroneus Longus → Cavus / Cavovarus Foot

  • Anatomy & Normal Function

    • Originates from lateral fibula; passes posterior to lateral malleolus to insert on 1st metatarsal base and medial cuneiform.

    • Functions:

      • Plantarflexes the 1st ray

      • Provides lateral column stability

      • Supports forefoot lever during push-off

  • Pathoanatomy

    • In neuromuscular disorders (e.g., Charcot-Marie-Tooth), peroneus longus remains relatively strong, while tibialis anterior and peroneus brevis weaken.

    • Result:

      • 1st ray plantarflexion → medial column rigidity and high arch

      • Progressive hindfoot varus and lateral column overload

    • Even subtle cavus may present with recurrent ankle instability and lateral foot pain.

  • Clinical Evaluation

    • Coleman block test:

      • If hindfoot varus corrects with lateral column support → deformity is forefoot-driven.

    • Assess 1st ray mobility and peroneal–tibialis anterior muscle balance.

    • Consider neuromuscular exam when appropriate.

  • Imaging

o   Lateral Foot

§  Meary’s Angle → increased apex dorsally

§  Calcaneal Pitch → elevated

§  Coleman relationship indirectly inferred

·       AP Foot

·       Forefoot adduction / supination assessment

·       Medial/lateral column comparative morphology

  • Gait & Kinetic Consequences

    • Plantarflexed 1st ray makes the foot rigid → decreased shock absorption.

    • Increased lateral loading → lateral column stress fractures, sinus tarsi pain.

    • Elevated ankle inversion moments → recurrent sprains and chronic instability.

    • Proximal chain effect: varus knee tendencies and compensatory hip/lumbar adaptations.

  • Management Overview

    • Nonoperative

      • Orthoses with lateral posting; gastrosoleus stretching; proprioceptive training.

    • Surgical Principles

      • Goal: plantigrade, balanced foot.

      • When PL “overdrive” is present:

        • Peroneus longus → brevis transfer to reduce 1st ray plantarflexion and improve eversion strength.

      • Structural corrections as needed:

        • 1st metatarsal dorsiflexion osteotomy

        • Calcaneal lateralizing osteotomy

        • Middle foot osteotomies for fixed deformity

    • Clinical Message: Addressing peroneus longus imbalance is critical; isolated bony correction without tendon balancing risks recurrence.

3. Gastrosoleus Complex → Equinus Deformity

  • Anatomy & Function

    • Gastrocnemius crosses knee and ankle; soleus acts at ankle only.

    • Unite as Achilles tendon; primary plantar flexor.

    • Controls tibial advancement eccentrically in stance and generate power during push-off.

  • Classification and Key Test

    • Silfverskiöld test

      • Dorsiflexion improves with knee flexion → isolated gastrocnemius tightness.

      • Dorsiflexion restricted even with knee flexion → combined gastrosoleus/Achilles contracture.

  • Pathoanatomy & Associated Problems

    • Chronic equinus limits dorsiflexion; compensations include:

      • Midfoot pronation and medial arch collapse (planovalgus)

      • Increased forefoot loading → metatarsalgia, plantar fasciitis, ulcers (especially in diabetes)

      • In neuromuscular disease → equinovarus combinations possible

  • Gait Effects

    • Early heel rise, toe-walking pattern, inefficient gait.

    • Proximal compensations: knee hyperextension, increased patellofemoral load, altered hip and lumbar mechanics.

    • Frequently worsens AAFD (Adult Acquired Flatfoot) progression; must be addressed in reconstruction planning.

  • Management Overview

    • Nonoperative: stretching programs, splinting, footwear modification.

    • Surgical

      • Isolated gastrocnemius contracture → gastrocnemius recession (e.g., Strayer).

      • Combined contracture → Achilles tendon lengthening.

    • Avoid over-lengthening to prevent calcaneus gait and loss of push-off strength.

4. Kinetic Chain, Gait Cycle, and Load Transfer

  • Gait Overview

    • One cycle: heel strike → subsequent heel strike of same limb.

    • Stance ≈ 60% (weight bearing), swing ≈ 40%.

    • Foot transitions sequentially through shock absorption → stabilization → propulsion.

  • Role of the Foot in the Kinetic Chain

    • Terminal interface of the lower limb kinetic chain.

    • Modulates ground reaction forces through tibia, knee, hip, and pelvis.

    • Subtalar motion influences tibial rotation and knee frontal/transverse plane mechanics.

  • Deformity-Specific Chain Effects

    •  Adult Acquired Flatfoot / Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity (AAFD / PCFD)

      • Excess pronation, hindfoot valgus → tibial internal rotation, valgus knee moment increase, reduced push-off efficiency.

    • Cavus / Cavovarus

      • Rigid medial column → lateral overload, stress injury risk, recurrent instability.

    • Equinus

      • Early heel-off, forefoot overload, compensatory midfoot pronation; mixed cavus–planovalgus patterns may appear across phases.

  • Practical Clinical & Surgical Principles

    • Always evaluate the entire kinetic chain, not only the foot.

    • In AAFD surgery:

      • Treat associated gastrosoleus tightness to prevent under-correction or recurrence.

    • In cavovarus reconstruction:

      • Assess and correct peroneus longus dominance; tendon balancing is essential.

    • In equinus management:

      • Standardize Silfverskiöld testing; incorrect Achilles lengthening leads to major functional compromise.

 

References

1-    Polichetti C, Borruto MI, Lauriero F, et al. Adult Acquired Flatfoot Deformity: A Narrative Review about Imaging Findings. Diagnostics (Basel). 2023;13(2):225. Published 2023 Jan 7. doi:10.3390/diagnostics13020225

2-    Myerson MS, Thordarson DB, Johnson JE, et al. Classification and Nomenclature: Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity. Foot Ankle Int. 2020;41(10):1271-1276. doi:10.1177/1071100720950722

3-    Ross MH, Smith M, Plinsinga ML, Vicenzino B. Self-reported social and activity restrictions accompany local impairments in posterior tibial tendon dysfunction: a systematic review. J Foot Ankle Res. 2018;11:49. Published 2018 Aug 30. doi:10.1186/s13047-018-0292-z

4-    Maynou C, Szymanski C, Thiounn A. The adult cavus foot. EFORT Open Rev. 2017;2(5):221-229. Published 2017 May 11. doi:10.1302/2058-5241.2.160077

5-    Henry JK, Shakked R, Ellis SJ. Adult-Acquired Flatfoot Deformity. Foot Ankle Orthop. 2019;4(1):2473011418820847. Published 2019 Jan 16. doi:10.1177/2473011418820847